Andy Cohen Reveals What He Pays His Babysitter & His Famous Friend Immediately Calls Him ‘Cheap’

There always seems to be a new debate about how much to pay babysitters and nannies, and the latest round comes to us courtesy of Andy Cohen. While talking to Jeff Lewis on his XM radio show this week, Andy revealed exactly how much he pays his babysitter to watch his two kids, and Jeff wasted no time letting him know exactly how “cheap” he thinks he is.

The problem? Andy really does not see a problem with what he pays, even after taking the time to do a little research.

A 23-year-old babysitter watches Andy’s kids, Benjamin and Lucy, as needed.

After he shared that he pays his New York City babysitter $30 an hour, Jeff was pretty shocked and let Andy know exactly how he feels.

“Oh, hmm. That sounds cheap to me. Especially from someone with your money,” Jeff said, per the Daily Mail. “She was there for two hours and you gave her sixty bucks? Did that even cover the cab?”

Ouch! But also, Jeff has a point — even just transportation to and from Andy’s place could have eaten into a good chunk of her earnings that night.

Meanwhile, Jeff pays his babysitter $37 an hour (though he added that he “probably would’ve given her a hundred for two hours, two kids,” since he only has a 9-year-old daughter) which is a big upgrade from $30. We can see why he balked at what Andy was offering!

Is Andy’s rate really enough in this economy?

Andy said that he threw in a little extra because he came home a little more than two hours later, but not much.

“She was there for two hours and fifteen minutes, so I gave her $70,” he said.

Jeff wasn’t super impressed by that, but some people would have been fine with Andy’s rate. According to UrbanSitter, most parents in NYC pay their babysitters somewhere between $22-26 an hour for their services, so all things considered, Andy’s going above and beyond here.

Babysitters are definitely going to appreciate a little extra cash, though — it can be a stressful job!

Even after having that conversation on air, Andy is only doubling down.

While talking to Page Six on Tuesday at the Broadcasting + Cable Hall of Fame Awards, Andy was even more confident that $30 an hour is the way to go.

He said that after his conversation with Jeff — who he said made him feel like a “cheapskate,” by the way — he “checked” with his other parent friends and found out that they all agree with his rate and don’t think he’s being cheap at all.

If it works for Andy and his babysitter, it works. But she probably wouldn’t mind a nice tip if he’s ever feeling especially generous.

READ NEXT: Andy Cohen Mocked Julia Stiles’ Dancing & She Just Got the Perfect Chance To Make Him Regret It