What to Know
For plenty of millennials, Lena Dunham is a genius writer who gave us HBO’s Girls and a ton of commentary on feminism, relationships, and everything in between. For other millennials, Lena is a polarizing figure whose writing never resonated with them. Naturally, because of these warring sides of fans versus haters, the reactions on Reddit to Lena announcing the birth of her first child via surrogacy were mixed.
Some people celebrated Lena getting her second win, not only as someone in the entertainment industry, but also as someone who was able to become a mother despite not being able to have children herself. Others condemned her for the use of a surrogate at all, and shared some pretty strong views on surrogacy.
Lena Dunham’s surrogacy birth plan drew heavy criticism.
Lena announced the birth of her first child with her husband, Luis Felber, through an op-ed she wrote for Vogue, which was published on Sept. 16, 2026. In the article, Lena wrote about being focused on her surrogate during the birth and being “in awe” of her. Her daughter was born almost two weeks past the surrogate’s original due date.
Because Lena opted to use a surrogate, though, and even wrote in that Vogue article about feeling a strange detachment from the process due to being able to go on a book tour and live her professional life while her baby grew inside of the surrogate, she faced immediate criticism. Maybe not from people who have supported Lena and her brutal honesty about herself, women, and men over the years. But the criticism was more so from those who had already made up their minds that they don’t like the writer and actress.
On Reddit, users went back and forth either congratulating Lena for welcoming her baby, or condemning her for using a surrogate. Others slammed her for alleged former problematic behavior that they feel the general public has chosen to forget.
One person wrote, “Genuine question: why is everyone celebrating this? Lena Dunham has a history of racism (which they have never apologized for) and admitted to acting like a child predator towards their younger sister.”
On the other side of the coin, another Reddit user commented on the same post, “Aw, I just finished her book, and she talks about how badly she wanted children. I’m happy for her that she was able to make it happen.”
Some of her fans defended her due to her severe endometriosis diagnosis.
In 2018, Lena wrote another op-ed for Vogue, in which she shared details of her endometriosis diagnosis. She also wrote that she elected to have a hysterectomy at 31.
At the time, she wrote of intense pain and numerous doctor’s office visits.
“In August, the pain becomes unbearable,” Lena wrote. “I am delirious with it, and the doctors can’t really explain. The ultrasound shows no cysts, no free fluid, and certainly no baby. But that doesn’t help the fact that it hurts so bad that the human voices around me have become a sort of nonsense Teletubbies singsong. With pain like this, I will never be able to be anyone’s mother. Even if I could get pregnant, there’s nothing I can offer.”
People are criticizing surrogacy as a whole.
On the Reddit thread with warring comments about Lena and her decision to use a surrogate to have a baby with her husband, several users slammed surrogacy as a practice in the United States. Some commented that women are being “used” for breeding and that surrogates are exploited in a major way.
“Ban surrogacy!” Someone commented. “It is also disgusting how Lena Dunham [is] considered a feminist by some. ‘Renting’ women’s wombs and traumatizing them for $$$ should not exist.”
“Renting wombs is messed up,” another user wrote. “I don’t understand how it’s so acceptable in America.”
But others responded to those same comments by supporting Lena after her inability to get pregnant herself.
READ NEXT: Tara Lipinski Welcomes Baby Girl Via Surrogate After Infertility Battle — See First Photos